A contractor says the invoice is overdue. The owner says the work is defective, delayed or incorrectly billed. Can the contractor obtain judgment for payment first and leave the owner’s complaints for another hearing?

McMaster Custom Builder Ltd. v 1276770 B.C. Ltd., 2026 BCSC 1961, shows why the answer depends on the evidence and how closely the claims are connected. The Supreme Court of British Columbia refused the requested summary determination and directed that both sides’ claims proceed to trial together.

What the contractor sought

The contractor applied under the summary-trial procedure for approximately $180,446 in unpaid amounts, plus interest. With contractual interest, its requested judgment exceeded $221,000 at the hearing date.

The owner disputed the claim and alleged deficient work, delay, improper billing and double billing. Its counterclaim arose from the same project and asserted a substantially larger loss. These were competing claims, not established findings that either side owed the amount alleged.

An eight-day trial was already scheduled for late November 2026 when the application was heard. That made the practical value of a separate determination an important issue.

Why a separate payment judgment was refused

Summary trial can resolve suitable cases without a conventional trial. The judge considered the record and attempted to determine whether the necessary facts could fairly be found through that procedure.

Here, the invoice claim and the counterclaim were closely intertwined. Deciding one first risked findings inconsistent with those later made at trial. There were issues that could benefit from cross-examination, and the evidentiary dispute was more complex than the contractor suggested.

The court also considered the cost of effectively litigating the dispute in pieces. Granting the requested judgment would not eliminate the need to try the counterclaim, and a trial was relatively near. On balance, the judge found it unjust to grant judgment in the requested manner.

What the ruling did not decide

The court dismissed the summary-trial application, not the contractor’s underlying claim on its merits. Both the contractor’s claim and the owner’s counterclaim were to proceed together. The owner received costs of the application, subject to the terms of the order.

The decision is therefore not a finding that the contractor performed defective work or that the owner could permanently refuse payment. It is a procedural decision about how the competing issues should be resolved fairly.

The reasons also should not be read as permission to ignore proper pleadings or expert-evidence rules. A disputed invoice, a defence and a claim for compensation need to be presented in the correct form.

Preparing a useful record

  • Keep the signed contract, change orders and communications about scope and price.
  • Match invoices and payment records to the work actually claimed.
  • Preserve dated photographs, inspection records and a chronology of alleged deficiencies.
  • Obtain advice about whether expert evidence is needed and how it must be prepared.

Be careful before withholding payment, agreeing to a final account or undertaking repairs that remove important evidence. The best response depends on the agreement, the condition of the work and the available remedies.

The takeaway

An invoice is not always a self-contained dispute when the same project gives rise to substantial counterclaims. Sinclair Centre Law LLP assists with contractual and civil disputes in British Columbia. Contact us to assess the documents, competing claims and a proportionate route toward resolution.

Sources and next steps