If the other party receives free legal help, it may be tempting to assume there is no legal bill for you to pay if you lose. That assumption can be wrong. The rules governing a costs award are not simply a mirror of the private payment arrangement between a lawyer and client.

Narejko v Li, 2026 BCCA 393, concerned a registrar’s assessment of special costs following a family-law appeal. The registrar assessed $34,518.40 despite the respondent having received pro bono representation.

What was being decided

The underlying dispute concerned whether the parties had reached a settlement in their divorce proceedings. The appeal had already been dismissed as an abuse of process, and special costs had been ordered.

The 2026 decision was the next stage: assessing the amount. It was a decision by the Court of Appeal’s registrar, not a new panel judgment deciding the divorce or re-hearing the appeal. The requested amount was $38,181.28 and included work associated with the assessment process.

Why free representation did not end the costs claim

The registrar rejected the proposition that pro bono services prevented recovery of special costs. The successful party’s arrangement with counsel did not automatically remove the consequences of the existing costs order.

The amount still required assessment. The registrar examined the work claimed and the circumstances, rather than simply approving the entire request. The decision noted that the appellant’s conduct had unnecessarily increased the length and complexity of what began as a relatively straightforward appeal.

The registrar also refused a request to recuse himself. The special-costs assessment was lower than the amount sought. Including a separate ordinary-costs award of $2,794.78, the certificate total was $37,313.18. The distinction matters when reading the different figures in the reasons.

Special costs are not the ordinary result of losing

Ordinary costs and special costs are different. This decision assessed an order already made in litigation that had been characterized as an abuse of process. It does not mean every unsuccessful family litigant must pay the other side’s full legal expenses.

Nor does it create a fixed price for an appeal. The underlying order, the work reasonably involved and the applicable assessment principles all matter. A headline dollar figure cannot substitute for advice about the risk in a particular case.

How to evaluate the risk before taking the next step

  • Read the current order carefully: has entitlement to costs already been decided?
  • Distinguish a disagreement with the result from a legally supportable appeal ground.
  • Consider how repetitive applications or unnecessary disputes may increase the work involved.
  • Ask for advice about settlement, proportionality and potential costs consequences.

The other party’s ability to obtain pro bono help should not determine whether you take a litigation step. Focus instead on its legal basis, likely benefit and financial risk. A genuine issue can deserve a hearing without every proposed argument or application advancing it.

The takeaway

Free representation does not necessarily mean zero exposure to an opposing costs award. Narejko is a reminder to assess procedural choices realistically and to understand the difference between an existing special-costs order and the later calculation of its amount.

Sinclair Centre Law LLP advises on family disputes and litigation strategy in British Columbia. Contact our Vancouver office to discuss a proposed appeal, an existing costs order or the options for resolving a family-law matter.

Sources and next steps